Minimed 530G with Enlite Trial, Threshold Suspend

Email this to someoneTweet about this on Twitter0Share on Facebook0Share on Google+0Pin on Pinterest0

Last week I started a trial of Medtronic’s latest insulin pump and continuous glucose monitoring system, the Minimed 530G with Enlite. (See my previous post here.) I thought I’d devote today’s post to what’s arguably the most exciting part of the new system: threshold suspend. 

As those of you who have been keeping up with the work toward developing a closed-loop insulin delivery system (the so-called Artificial Pancreas) know, threshold suspend is the first step in the long journey toward that goal. (You, like me, may also have been irritated by the marketing that surrounded the 530G and used the word “artificial pancreas,” since it was picked up and oversimplified by the news media to suggest that this system actually is an artificial pancreas, which it is most definitely not.) 

Threshold suspend, which has been available on Medtronic’s Veo pump/CGM system in Europe since 2009, means that if your blood glucose reaches a certain predetermined level (anywhere from 60-90 mg/dL), your insulin pump will alarm, warning you of a potentially dangerous low. If you respond to the warning, nothing will happen.  Minimed 530G with Enlite Trial, Threshold SuspendBut if you do not respond to that warning, the pump will shut off basal insulin delivery for two hours. (Then it will go on for four hours, then off for another two, etc, till someone clears the alarm.) The idea is simple: if you’ve got a low blood sugar and are not responding, the last thing you need is more insulin. 

When I set up my 530G system last week, I was hoping not to have to experience the benefits of Threshold Suspend firsthand. I’m lucky enough to never have passed out or been sent to the hospital as a result of a low blood sugar, and thanks to my CGM, usually am able to stave off bad nighttime lows. So I was surprised when I found myself roused from sleep my first night on the system by two-tone alarm of my pump going off, and the message on its screen that said Threshold Suspend. A quick scan of my body confirmed what it was suggesting: my heart was racing, and I felt shaky. My blood sugar was indeed low. And whereas I’m normally able to correct for a low with two glucose tablets (even that sometimes sends me too high), that night I took five glucose tablets and never had a spike above 130 mg/dL. In other words, I’m glad that it went off. 

With that said, I’ve also found some things about the Threshold Suspend function to be unsatisfying/annoying. First, it isn’t predictive, meaning that it will only shut off once you’ve already reached your predetermined target (the next generation will hopefully have this capability). But second, there are some aspects of Threshold Suspend that I worry will limit its use. For example, you can only set your limit from 60 mg/dL to 90 mg/dL (kind of odd, since you can set other aspects of the pump as low as 40 mg/dL). I have mine set at 60 mg/dL, as low as it’ll go, but I don’t think it’s low enough: I often touch 60 mg/dL over the course of the day, and I don’t consider those lows to be emergency situations, since I’m alert and easily able to correct it. I would like to have the option to set it lower.

Second, I would like to be able to create two targets for Threshold Suspend: one for the nighttime, and one for the day (and a temporary snooze function). I say this because, as mentioned, a low of 60 mg/dL when I’m alert and awake is not an emergency situation. But the pump’s Threshold Suspend function INSISTS that it’s an emergency. The alarm does not start with a vibration — it goes straight into full on alarm mode. This means that if you are in a situation where you don’t want to risk having a siren emanate from your body — say a meeting or interview or yoga class — then your only option is to turn off Threshold Suspend. That might be fine for the moment, but it puts you at risk of forgetting to turn it back on for the times you really do need it, particularly before you go to sleep. And if the sensor is giving you an inaccurate reading — which is quite possible on any CGM system — then it’s even worse: you can have your pump start to go bat-sh*t crazy on you when you aren’t even low. 

All this brings up a point that I predict I will be reiterating throughout this trial: I wish that there had been more patient input in the design of the 530G, particularly when it comes to alarms. I do not know what type of trials were done before the system was submitted to FDA for approval, but I cannot imagine following a real person with tightly controlled diabetes around for three days and not concluding that the current limits for Threshold Suspend are too high, and that you should be able to set different limits for different times of day (and that the nighttime alarm should be louder — by the time I woke up, insulin delivery had already been suspended). As it is now, I really do worry that the annoyance of having a siren go off every time my blood glucose hits 60 mg/dL is eventually going to make me either turn it off (and forget to turn it back on), or turn it off entirely. And that would defeat the main added benefit of this particular pump.

With that said, I think that the Threshold Suspend feature of the 530G system is a great advance in diabetes care. I also think that integrated pump and CGM systems — especially those that can ward off potential dangerous lows — are essential for people with diabetes, and I believe that insurance companies and payers like Medicare should cover them. That’s probably the most important message of all. 

Email this to someoneTweet about this on Twitter0Share on Facebook0Share on Google+0Pin on Pinterest0

Comments (4)

  1. Barbara at

    Catherine—the Threshold Suspend worried me when I first heard it described months ago.  Your description was great as to the alarm levels. However, the idea of cutting off basal insulin is what makes me wonder.  Technically, I think, all insulin is directed toward the future in the sense that it’s going to work at its best a little later than when it enters our respective bodies.  That means that you are turning off basal insulin that your body is going to need later. You are not turning “off” what is most active right at the minute the alarm goes off.  I would be happy if someone would explain this and straighten out my thinking?

  2. Yes, Barbara, you’re right: basal insulin doesn’t work immediately, so threshold suspend is not “turning off” the insulin that’s causing the low (that’s why we need even faster insulins or a stable form of glucagon that could be administered via pump). However, it may help prevent you from going even lower say, if you’re sleeping. So it’s definitely a good thing, though you’re correct that its effects will not be as immediate as we’d like. 

  3. Rob at

    I asked about this device a couple weeks ago, wanting to know if I could set suspend at 100 mg/dl. Since I run my pump to create a very slight downward trend during normal days, if something occurs that causes me to exert myself, I can drop 40 – 60 mg/dl from a mild exertion if I am already below 100 mg/dl.  

    The part I don’t want is the off for two hours, but I haven’t received the contact from Medtronic I requested from my Endocrinologist. As a volunteer first responder, I have situations where it would be great for it to auto-suspend at  100 mg/dl, but then reactivate when it comes back above 100 mg/dl.

    Maybe you are different, but a basal that has me losing 5 mg/dl per hour at 110 mg/dl causes me to lose 20+ mg/dl per hour below 80 mg/dl.

  4. Catherine at

    Hi Rob, 
    Thanks for the comment. So, you can only set the threshold suspend between 60-90 mg/dL. And the idea of threshold suspend is that it’ll stop insulin delivery, so there’s no way to customize it in the way you describe. HOWEVER, you still might benefit from the predictive alerts on the 530G — in other words, you could set the pump/cgm to give you a warning when your blood sugar is moving in a way that indicates you’re going to dip below 100 mg/dL within a certain period of time (say, 30 minutes or so). Then you could decide whether or not you wanted to set an extremely low temp basal for yourself for a couple hours to try to ward off a potential low. Does that make sense? In other words, the threshold suspend feature wouldn’t really work for the purpose you’re describing, but the predictive alerts would help. And — correct me if I’m wrong, people — I *think* that the predictive alerts are available on the Revel, too. So if you’re currently on a Medtronic pump, you could add the Medtronic CGM without having to get the whole new 530G system (since its main new feature, threshold suspend, is something that it sounds like you don’t want).

    If you were on a Dexcom CGM you could also have it alert you when your blood sugar starts falling quickly, though it doesn’t have a specific “predictive” feature in the way the medtronic and former abbott systems do/did.

    hope that helps! 

Add a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

***The opinions and views expressed in this blog belong to the individual contributor and not to ASweetLife or its editors. All information contained on this blog is intended for informational purposes only. The information is not intended to be a replacement or substitute for consultation with a qualified medical professional or for professional medical advice related to diabetes or another medical condition. Please contact your physician or medical professional with any questions and concerns about your medical condition.